—
Standing in the garden center, you’re faced with a choice: cherry tomatoes or regular (slicing) tomatoes?
Or maybe you’re thinking: “Why not both?” (Spoiler: This is the right answer.)
But if you’re limited on space or just starting out, understanding the difference between cherry and regular tomatoes helps you make the best choice for YOUR situation.
Let me break down the pros and cons of each so you can decide.
## Cherry Tomatoes: The Overachievers
What they are: Small tomatoes (typically 1-2 inches diameter), often round but sometimes pear or grape-shaped. Seriously, they’re like tomato-flavored candy.
### Cherry Tomato Pros:
✅ Produce like CRAZY: One plant can give you hundreds of tomatoes over the season
✅ Fast to mature: 50-65 days from transplant to harvest
✅ More disease-resistant: Generally tougher and less prone to problems
✅ Perfect for containers: Most varieties do great in pots
✅ Continuous harvest: Indeterminates keep producing all season
✅ Kid-friendly: Easy to pop in your mouth, fun to pick
✅ Less blossom end rot: Smaller fruits = less calcium needed
✅ Great for snacking: No slicing needed, just rinse and eat
✅ Forgiving: Tolerate inconsistent watering better than large tomatoes
✅ Amazing flavor: Often sweeter and more intense flavor than regular tomatoes
### Cherry Tomato Cons:
❌ Not ideal for sandwiches: Too small for slicing (though you can halve them)
❌ Can’t make “proper” tomato salad: Caprese with cherry tomatoes is… weird
❌ Time-consuming to harvest: You’ll be out there picking individual tomatoes constantly
❌ Can split easily: Especially after rain or irregular watering
❌ Overwhelming production: Seriously, you’ll have SO MANY
❌ Not great for canning whole: Too small for most whole-tomato canning recipes
### Best Cherry Tomato Varieties:
– Sungold: Orange-gold, incredibly sweet, THE gateway tomato
– Sweet 100: Classic red cherry, super productive
– Black Cherry: Dark purplish-brown, complex flavor
– Yellow Pear: Pear-shaped, mild and sweet
– Juliet: Grape-shaped, meaty, great for roasting
### Best Uses for Cherry Tomatoes:
– Fresh snacking (duh)
– Salads
– Roasted (toss with olive oil, roast at 400°F for 20 minutes—amazing)
– Pasta dishes
– Skewers and appetizers
– Kids’ lunchboxes
– Giving away to neighbors (because you’ll have too many)
## Regular (Slicing) Tomatoes: The Classics
What they are: Medium to large tomatoes (3-6+ inches diameter) meant for slicing. These are your sandwich tomatoes, your BLT tomatoes, your “slice and eat with salt” tomatoes.
### Regular Tomato Pros:
✅ Perfect for sandwiches and burgers: That’s what they’re designed for
✅ Great for slicing: One tomato makes multiple slices
✅ Easier to harvest: Pick a few large tomatoes vs. dozens of cherry tomatoes
✅ Classic tomato experience: That “big, juicy tomato” everyone pictures
✅ Better for canning/sauce (some varieties): Roma and paste tomatoes are slicing-sized
✅ Impressive: There’s something satisfying about a huge, beautiful tomato
✅ Versatile: Work for fresh eating, cooking, canning
✅ Fewer to pick: Great if you don’t have time to harvest constantly
### Regular Tomato Cons:
❌ Slower to mature: 70-85+ days typically
❌ More prone to problems: Blossom end rot, cracking, splitting
❌ Need more care: Consistent watering is MORE critical
❌ Lower yields: Produce fewer pounds per plant than cherry tomatoes (usually)
❌ More demanding: Require better conditions for good production
❌ Larger plants: Especially heirlooms—need serious support
❌ Less forgiving: Stress affects them more than cherry tomatoes
### Best Regular Tomato Varieties:
For slicing:
– Early Girl: Fast, reliable, classic flavor
– Better Boy: Large (1 pound), disease-resistant
– Big Beef: Huge (10-12 oz), excellent flavor
– Brandywine: Heirloom, incredible flavor, slow but worth it
For sauce/canning:
– Roma: Classic paste tomato, meaty, low seeds
– San Marzano: Premium sauce tomato, sweet and meaty
– Amish Paste: Large paste tomato, versatile
### Best Uses for Regular Tomatoes:
– Sandwiches and burgers
– Sliced with mozzarella (Caprese salad)
– Tomato salads
– Sliced and eaten fresh with salt
– Sauce and canning (paste types)
– Grilling (thick slices)
– Stuffing (hollow out and stuff with filling)
## Head-to-Head Comparison
### Ease of Growing:
Winner: Cherry tomatoes
They’re more forgiving, faster-growing, and more disease-resistant. If you’re a beginner, start with cherry tomatoes.
### Yield (Total Pounds Per Plant):
Winner: Cherry tomatoes (usually)
One indeterminate cherry tomato plant can produce 20-30+ pounds. Regular tomatoes: 15-25 pounds.
BUT if you’re counting individual fruits, regular tomatoes obviously give you fewer (bigger) tomatoes.
### Speed to Harvest:
Winner: Cherry tomatoes
50-65 days vs. 70-85+ days for most regular tomatoes.
### Flavor:
Winner: Tie (personal preference)
Cherry tomatoes are often sweeter and more intense. Regular tomatoes (especially heirlooms) have more complex, balanced flavor.
You can’t go wrong either way—it’s just different.
### Versatility:
Winner: Regular tomatoes
Slicing tomatoes work for more recipes and uses. Cherry tomatoes are more limited (though still delicious).
### Container Growing:
Winner: Cherry tomatoes
Most cherry varieties thrive in pots. Many large slicing tomatoes struggle in containers.
### Low-Maintenance:
Winner: Cherry tomatoes
They tolerate neglect better. Regular tomatoes punish inconsistent care with blossom end rot, cracking, and poor production.
## Which Should YOU Grow?
### Grow Cherry Tomatoes If:
– You’re a beginner
– You want maximum production with minimum fuss
– You have limited space or grow in containers
– You want fast results
– You love snacking on tomatoes
– You have kids (they love picking cherry tomatoes)
– You want something nearly foolproof
### Grow Regular Tomatoes If:
– You want tomatoes for sandwiches and slicing
– You plan to can or make sauce
– You have space and proper supports
– You’re willing to provide consistent care
– You want that “classic big tomato” experience
– You’re drawn to heirlooms and diverse flavors
### Grow BOTH If:
You’re smart and have even moderate space!
The perfect combo:
– 2-3 cherry tomato plants (constant snacking supply)
– 3-4 slicing tomatoes (sandwiches, cooking, canning)
– Maybe 1-2 paste tomatoes if you make sauce
This gives you variety, constant harvests, and tomatoes for every use.
## Space Considerations
Limited space (balcony, small patio):
– Prioritize cherry tomatoes (especially compact varieties like Tiny Tim)
– Maybe 1 slicing tomato in a large container if you really want slices
Medium space (small raised bed, patio):
– 2 cherry tomatoes + 2 slicing tomatoes
– Perfect balance
Large space (full garden):
– Go wild! Plant 5+ of each, experiment with varieties
## Beginner’s Choice: Start With Cherry Tomatoes
If I could only give ONE piece of advice to new tomato growers, it’s this:
Start with cherry tomatoes.
Why? Because success breeds confidence. Cherry tomatoes are SO easy that you’ll actually get tomatoes, feel accomplished, and want to keep gardening. They’re the gateway drug to tomato obsession.
Once you’ve grown cherry tomatoes successfully, branch out to regular tomatoes the next season.
## The “Best of Both Worlds” Variety
Looking for something in between? Try grape tomatoes or Juliet tomatoes.
They’re larger than cherry tomatoes but smaller than slicers. You get:
– Easier to grow than large tomatoes
– Big enough to halve for salads
– Still very productive
– Faster than regular tomatoes
Juliet is especially great—prolific, crack-resistant, and perfect for everything from fresh eating to roasting.
## Common Myths
Myth: Cherry tomatoes are “lesser” tomatoes
Nope! They’re just as flavorful (often MORE so) than regular tomatoes. They’re not “practice” tomatoes—they’re legitimate favorites for many experienced gardeners.
Myth: You can’t can cherry tomatoes
You CAN, but they’re not ideal for traditional canning. They work better for freezing, roasting and freezing, or making small-batch jams/chutneys.
Myth: Regular tomatoes taste better
Personal preference. Many people prefer the intense sweetness of cherry tomatoes.
Myth: Cherry tomatoes are only for kids
Tell that to fancy restaurants that charge $18 for a plate of heirloom cherry tomatoes with burrata. Cherry tomatoes are gourmet!
## The Bottom Line
Cherry tomatoes: Fast, productive, forgiving, perfect for snacking. The beginner’s best friend.
Regular tomatoes: Classic, versatile, perfect for slicing. The sandwich-lover’s choice.
The real answer: Grow both if you can. If you can’t, start with cherry tomatoes—they’re easier and more rewarding for beginners.
You honestly can’t make a wrong choice here. Any homegrown tomato is 1000x better than store-bought. Whether it’s tiny and sweet or big and juicy, you’re going to love it.
Now go plant some tomatoes! (Preferably both kinds.) 🍅
